Isn’t the Hike Challenging Enough?

So here we are, in the arena of the Appalachian Trail.  There have been blood, sweat (lots of it), and tears.  It is an emotional dig that will expose your strengths and will lay out your weaknesses for every living being to gawk at.  All of the insecurities and questionable aspects about yourself are put on full-blast exposure for you to dissect on a daily basis.  This trail has a 25% success rate.  That’s pretty freaking low.  It is a true challenge.

But apparently this challenge is not enough.  There are a few challenges or traditions that have become popular on the AT.  They break up the hike and monotony of walking forever.  I get it.  But I just can’t participate.  There are so many ways to get creative on the trail without ruining a meal and/or risking injury or exhaustion.

Ice Cream Half-Gallon Challenge

Description: The ice cream challenge is at the approximate halfway point for NOBOs.  You eat 1.5 quart tub of Hershey’s ice cream and a pint of hand-scooped ice cream.

My personal thoughts: I guess in terms of getting a crap ton of calories in one shot: success.  I actually considered doing my own half-gallon challenge after Katahdin to honor my flip flop halfway point.  But I just can’t get down.  Yes, I can do it, but should I?  It’s just too much at once.  Many hikers who have attempted it have vomited, while eating it, in front of others still eating their ice cream.  Gross.  They even suggest not getting your favorite flavor in order to not ruin that flavor for the future.  I like ice cream, but in moderation.  I’d rather indulge in a cold treat and not make myself sick with gluttonous acts.

Four-State Challenge

Description: Hike through four states in one day.  Wake up in Virginia, walk through West Virginia and Maryland, and end the day over the border in Pennsylvania.

My personal thoughts: Whoa buddy, slow down! There is so much history in West Virginia and Maryland.  War monuments and historical sites are waiting for you around so many turns of the trail.  It is obviously a feasible task, especially for NOBOs, but it doesn’t give those states you blow past the respect they deserve.  There are 14 states on the trail.  They each have a unique blend of flora and fauna.  I want to explore and do my best to appreciate every state I pass through.  Even Pennsylvania and the rocks.  Speaking of, why are you excited to get to Pennsylvania?  I’m from PA and even I’m not fooled.

Connecticut Challenge

Description: Hike through Connecticut in 24 hours.

My personal thoughts: Connecticut is actually really pretty.   The trail is well marked and labeled.  Heaven dirt is everywhere.  Heaven dirt is the trail floor that actually feels good on your feet.  It often consists of dirt, grass, pine needles, and a little bounce.  Oh, and the shelters have limited to no graffiti! Slow it down my friend, enjoy.  Give Connecticut the respect it also deserves.

Challenges I Support (aka, I Made Up)

  • Make it through Pennsylvania without complaining about the rocks. I dare you
  • Save a millipede day. Move those baby choo choo trains off the trail.
  • Give a pound to every hiker you see in a day and tell them, “You rock!” Especially day hikers who may be struggling on an incline
  • Don’t talk about gear or the trail.

*All of this is my personal opinion.  You did or want to do these challenges?  Go you!  You want to hang out on Annapolis Rock in Maryland with me and paint the view?  Let’s do it!

Affiliate Disclosure

This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!

To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.

Comments 7

  • Backwardshatforwardthinking : Jun 5th

    So you don’t like any of the challenges, then why write about it? It’s about the experience… just like hiking. And you missed to list a handful of challenges, all of which you would probably pass on as well.

  • Don't Care : Jun 5th

    Don’t talk about gear? For a whole day? That’s just crazy talk!

  • Mudpie : Jun 11th

    Here’s one to add to the list….don’t talk about food.

    • Alexia : Jun 15th

      That’s a good one! I would fail. I dream about food lol.

  • Sidewinder with Red Rudder and Turnup : Jun 23rd

    I am proud to say I have not stepped on a millipede yet! An as for your impossible Pennsylvania Rock Challenge…epic FAIL! Looking forward to seeing you on the trail and bringing you magical trail doggie kisses!

  • james : Jul 9th

    Nice Post


What Do You Think?