New Hampshire Officials Say an Unprepared Hiker Must Pay for His Own Rescue
New Hampshire Fish and Game officials rescued an unprepared hiker near the Franconia Ridge on Sunday evening and plan to charge the individual for the cost of the operation.
Hiker Rescued From New Hampshire’s Franconia Ridge
The agency received an emergency call at approximately 6:03 p.m. on Sunday, October 19 regarding a hiker requesting assistance near the summit of Little Haystack Mountain in Lincoln, New Hampshire. The hiker was identified as Jayson Choy, 23, of East Hampstead, NH. He was located above the treeline on the Franconia Ridge Trail.
Choy informed Conservation Officers that he was unprepared, lacking essential supplies including water, food, and a headlamp. With temperatures falling and a storm system approaching, officers initiated a rescue hike.
A Conservation Officer located Choy just below Little Haystack’s summit on the Falling Waters Trail at 8:14 p.m. Choy was provided with the necessary food, water, and a light before being escorted down the trail. They arrived back at the parking lot at approximately 9:50 p.m.

The hiker was still above tree line at the time of the call. Photo
After the Rescue
Choy, who was uninjured, stated he had not anticipated the hike would take as long as it did, leaving him unprepared for the conditions. Fish and Game confirmed that Choy will be charged for the expenses incurred during the rescue operation. The dollar amount for the rescue remains unknown.
Fish and Game used the incident to remind the public that hikers should always carry the proper equipment. They urge hikers to pack the ten essential items — including warm clothing, extra food and water, and a headlamp — before heading out into the mountains.
Is It Normal To Pay for Search and Rescue?
In a word — no. New Hampshire is one of the only states that somewhat regularly charges for search and rescue in cases it deems preventable.
A handful of other US states, including Maine and Oregon, have laws enabling them to charge for rescues that result from negligence. But in practice, the rescued parties are almost never billed.
The practice of charging for rescue is controversial. Some say it’s warranted in cases where a recreationist’s own negligence led to a costly and, in some cases, dangerous rescue mission. Others argue that the fear of an expensive bill will discourage people from calling for help when they need it.
Even in New Hampshire, it is still rare for the rescued party to end up footing the bill. New Hampshire Fish and Game carried out an average of 189 rescues per year between FY 2009 and 2019 at a total cost of roughly $3.1 million. According to the Appalachian Mountain Club, an average of 17 of those operations were billed to the person rescued.
Note: if you purchase a Hike Safe card from New Hampshire Fish and Game, you will not be charged for your rescue even if you’re found to have been negligent. This voluntary card costs $25 and is valid for the entire calendar year in which you purchased it.
This article was updated on 27 October 2025 to include information about New Hampshire Fish and Game’s Hike Safe card.
This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!
To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.
">
Comments 13
By these numbers, each rescue over a 10 year period (2009-2019), averaged $1,640.21 a rescue. Probably closer to $2,000 in 2025.
Yes, I believe the person that dials 911 to be rescued should be charged to put all those resources in motion.
I read about a lot of rescues made for hikers and it seems that at least 75% of them had no business out on the trail. I think that they should have to pay for the rescue.
Welcome to NH. They are changing there state moto from live free or die to live, freeze, or die.
I think that the Whites proximity to so many urban communities leads to a lot of inexperienced folks taking to the trail for the weekend unprepared. I flew out to LaGuardia and hiked with a friend of my dad’s from Hanover to Mt. Madison and down. We ran into a dude who was in his 50s at Lake Of The Clouds. He was overweight and his pack must have weighed 40+ pounds and he was just out for 3 days staying in AMC Huts. His knee looked like a bowling ball. I was 13 and this was 1973 so most packs had aluminum frames. We managed to tie his pack onto the top of my Jansport pack and my dad’s buddy helped him get down. Even if you know what you’re doing, accidents happen. When no accident occurs and you need a rescue as a result of foolishness, you should pay! The dude we helped didn’t even offer us a ride or pizza. I thru hiked the Long Trail the next year and met nobody I’ll prepared. Thru hiked the AT in 81 and celebrated my 21st BD in Monson. Again, only in the Whites do you encounter these situations on a yearly basis.
Should have to show gross negligence. By definition any accident or incident could be prevented by not going into the wilderness or national forest.
I can tell you from real life experience that it does make people hesitate or refuse to reach out when they know that it could cost them more than they have. Guess you want to send spouses or parents the bill after you haul frozen corpses out of woods as well.
The legal term gross negligence refers to an act showing a severe and reckless disregard for the lives or safety of another person. While ordinary negligence involves the failure to provide an adequate level of care or caution.
Negligence was key in this case – he went in unprepared, without the essentials. This is negligence on his part. 4 rules to live by in the outdoors: 1) ALWAYS pack the essentials. 2) CHECK weather reports and, if possible, trail conditions. 3) KNOW your limits. 4) ALWAYS let someone know your route and expected returns time. Following these will go a long way in assuring a safe return under all but the most extreme circumstances.
Oh, the absolute financial ruin! We are talking about a staggering $3.1 million spent on Search and Rescue operations over an entire decade. Let’s crunch those massive, bloated numbers: a crippling annual average of three hundred and ten thousand dollars. How dare they drain the public coffers like that? Why, that monstrous budget is less than what my own town allocates for the truly essential, life-or-death municipal service of street sweeping. Since public safety is clearly a secondary concern to the all-important balance sheet, we must, of course, prioritize our relentless pursuit of minimal “cost recovery.” After all, what’s a small, inevitable public death or two in the face of maintaining such truly impressive, penny-pinching budget?
Amen that. I made a lot of boneheaded mistakes when I was in my 20’s mostly because of my sense of invulnerability at that age. Fortunately nature was a kind teacher and I never suffered anything too serious, mostly hunger and cold, uncomfortable nights, but I gained wisdom and skill and now try to pass it on kindly to the younger adventurers. People make mistakes and people learn. I’d hate to think of a younger person perishing because they are afraid they can’t afford help.
What if the next unprepared hiker decides he can’t afford paying for a rescue and tries to return without any help? Lessons learned, right?
I agree that people should pay for rescue when A. They are engaged in a risky/extreme endeavor like mountain climbing, rock climbing, etc., , or B. They set out on adventures unprepared. When I travel, I buy travel insurance to cover the unexpected. Adventurers should do the same, because why should you and I (taxpayers), foot the bill for people doing things we would not do when they go wrong?
Years ago, we had a story here in the west of someone who was in need of rescue and in danger of dying. As they communicated with rescuers, they were reluctant to tell them where they were or request for help to reach them. They finally got it out of hiker that they could not afford to pay the bill of being rescued.
I think it is bad policy to blanket enforce payment because of the potential for tragedy. Young people in particular are prone to do dumb things. Silly for them to lose their life over a rescue fee. Mandatory community service would be a better substitute.
Generally, rescues are good training for the pro rescuers. There are exceptions of course.
Trek – do better. Good grief, so many people think that buying the NH Hike Safe card will relieve you of paying rescue costs, and that is simply not true. It’s articles like this that give them that impression. Directly from the NH Hike Safe website – less than 10 seconds of research – “People who obtain the cards are not liable to repay rescue costs if they need to be rescued. An individual may still be liable for response expenses if the actions that created the need for the emergency response meet criteria set forth by legislation.” In other words, if you are deemed negligent, or were taking a risk, or were irresponsible, holding a Hike Safe card won’t protect you from being charged.