What I Didn’t Tell You About My Flip-Flop
I left off writing at the edge of the 100-Mile Wilderness. I planned two more posts, one about the Hundred-Mile, the last about Katahdin, but I couldn’t write them.
After Katahdin I was home, as I’d planned to be. I’d be back in Wisconsin a week, get another cortisone shot for my arthritic knee, spend time with my wife, see friends, then catch Amtrak back to Pawling and push south to Springer.
That was the plan, the one I told you about. But the truth is, by the time I hit Maine, I’d stopped believing it.
I didn’t tell you that.
I had my reasons, and they were good ones.
Heading south would have meant finishing in December and a flip within my flop to get through the Smokies before snow turned the trail into a post-holing nightmare.
Then there were my spring classes to prep (I still teach), my wife’s birthday, an election to vote in, and one more Boundary Waters trip to take. Plus, I looked forward to resuming my barista job. I was excited about improving my latte art and counter skills.
Better to come back next year, I told myself. Better weather, more time, and a straight shot to Georgia. I would finish the first week of November. Perfect.
I’d thru-hiked the PCT and the CDT. I was fine doing the AT as a two-part LASH. I had nothing to prove.
That’s what I told myself.
Unlike Killington in 2024, getting off the AT this time wasn’t a surrender. It was a conscious choice. I would be back next summer, but I would return as a section hiker. And to my surprise, that mattered. A lot.
Many of us deal with depression after getting off trail. I am a member of this sad clan. On trail I made new friends, shared parts of myself that hadn’t seen the light of day in years, shed pounds, and became crazy-fit while eating like a joyful pig.
Being on trail expanded my life and gave it purpose by shrinking it. The daily routine of miles and chores, the resupply stops of splurge and cleansing, and the slow accretion of accomplishment.
But now, back home and staying, that bigger life has abruptly ended. The better version of myself, the one who crushed miles despite the bad joints, is slowly fading.
I’ve been following Guru on Instagram, the guy in the kilt I hiked the 100-Mile Wilderness and summited Katahdin with. Seeing his photos of autumn sunsets, fall-stripped trees and leaf-strewn trails, I can smell the damp leaves, feel the cold air. I think, “That could have been me.”
Getting through the Whites showed me what my old body could do. My confidence only grew as I clambered through the Mahoosucs, the Bigelows, and hard sections with no name. I flew over the roots and rocks of Maine, nearly ecstatic. When I climbed Katahdin, I was at my peak.
There are no guarantees I’ll come back and finish. Not for lack of desire, but because of my waning ability. My arthritis, my stamina, and who knows what other shoe might drop between now and next July.
I now believe I should have kept going. It’s not just that I can’t trust my body; it’s like I broke a promise to myself.
When I set out to hike the Triple Crown in 2022, the subtext read “thru-hike.” My dad’s passing, and my AT attempt in 2024 that followed, changed the rules. It seemed that just finishing, no matter the method, was all that mattered.
I was wrong.
I am a thru-hiker. An identity of which I am ridiculously proud. I’ve had my face wind-blasted raw below whooshing turbines outside Tehachapi, been chased by wildfires through Oregon, and dragged a norovirus-weakened body through the Cascades. On the CDT, I pushed through joint pain requiring oral steroids in the Wind River Range and dunked frost-stiffened shoes into the Gila River so I could jam my frozen feet into them. To get off trail 6,000 miles into my Triple Crown, even by choice, now feels like a betrayal of what I set out to do.
It took me a long time to write this post. I’d planned to keep writing my way to Katahdin, a story I still need to tell. But I had to come clean first. Thank you for following me this far.
Next time, I’ll tell you about the Hundred-Mile.
This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!
To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.
">
Comments 11
This is so honest and vulnerable. Thanks for writing. I hope you can find some peace with your decision. A specific decision is rarely “right” or “wrong.” When is the universe asking you to learn, here?
Thanks for reading, Amy, and for the kind words. I agree, the decision itself wasn’t right or wrong. It just had a cost I didn’t see coming. As for the lesson, I suspect I’ll understand it better next summer, when I’m hiking to Georgia.
This is beautifully written and I understand what you are saying but remember the other rule of long distance hiking is “Hike your own hike”. You did.
Thank you, Lisa. I did. Despite my regrets at getting off trail, I had a hell of a hike. Let me say this about the AT. Compared to the PCT and the CDT, mile for mile, the AT is the most brutal. The trail is demanding, the climbs and descents are sometimes scary, and there were times when I felt physically beat up and emotionally battered. But, God, I had a great time.
It’s all good.
No problem.
Good luck.
Hike your own hike.
Cheers!
Thanks, Tentman. Hiking your own hike, I’ve learned, isn’t always easy. My split flip-flop, finishing next year, seemed like a great plan in Maine. It wasn’t until I’d been home a month that I felt what it cost me. But I’ve made peace with it. The plus side: I don’t have to decide what trail to hike next. I’m finishing the AT, and I’m REALLY looking forward to it.
“I am a thru hiker,” you say. It sounds like you’re many other things, too, including wise and thoughtful. I hope you find peace. I have enjoyed your journal and look forward to hearing your take on the 100 Mile Wilderness. And please tell us, what do you stand on when you pose behind the Katahdin sign?
Thank you, that’s generous. And yes, I’m more than a thru-hiker. It’s just the part of me that feels most important right now. I’m working on the 100-Mile Wilderness post this weekend. Long time coming. As for the Katahdin sign, there are wooden crossboards behind it. The lowest is broken, so you have to heft yourself up to the highest, and there, braced, you strike your pose.
Thank you for telling the rest of your story . . . well, the rest of the chapter, because you still have more story to live and tell. I followed a number of hikers on the AT this year via Instagram. I’m not sure how I stumbled on your videos, but they were always a pleasure to listen to.
Thank you, Deb. I like that: “the rest of the chapter.” The next one starts next summer, heading south to Georgia. I’m glad you found the videos were worth the listen.
Even though I won’t be living near the trail by then, I’ll still watch for your Instagram posts. And now I just sadly realized that my days of picking up random hikers coming through my area will be over when I move. I heard some wonderful stories through the years (and had one strange dude that I couldn’t wait to get out of my car).