You Can Do Trail Magic, You Just Have to Do it Right

It’s no mystery why hikers in the midst of a grueling long-distance journey love trail magic. Whether you’re having a great day or feeling ground down, hot, cold, tired, or sore, an unexpected treat or random act of kindness by a stranger — food, a ride to town, sage advice, a clean privy — can provide an instant jolt of joy and gratitude.

appalachian trail magic virginia

John “Evil” Stout of Glade Spring, Va., provides trail magic to Anna “Soupspot” where the AT crosses VA 603. Photo: Clay Bonnyman Evans

But here’s a secret: The people who provide all that generosity and serendipity will tell you that they get just as much out of it as hikers, maybe even more. Here is just a sampling of the rewards trail angels reap from their good deeds:

–The warm-fuzzy feeling of bringing joy to tired hikers, aka the “helper’s high,” which has been demonstrated by science.

–Soaking up hiker vibes and stories (and politely ignoring the funk), especially for those who cannot undertake a long hike of their own.

–The knowledge that they are “paying it forward” and “being the change” when they tidy up a privy, pick up micro-trash, or move branches off the trail.

So, everyone loves magic, right?

Well, not quite. In recent years, this venerable tradition on long trails has come under fire from critics who say it’s ruining the experience and even harming the trail, especially on the AT. There are some legitimate concerns, to be sure, but I think the problem has been overblown. You can do magic — you just have to do it right.

Magic Marred?

appalachian trail tent virginia

A hiker’s tent in a field near Newport, Va. Photo: Clay Bonnyman Evans.

Still, as a hiker who has both given and received trail magic, on the Appalachian and Colorado trails, I find the current wave of anti-magic sentiment a tad… overwrought.

In my thousands of miles of long-distance hiking, I have never met a hiker who seriously altered her plans to take advantage of rumored magic; magic is not as ubiquitous as some critics claim — on the AT I experienced no magic at all for more than 700 miles between Grayson Highlands, Va., and New York; I never expected magic — it was always serendipitous — but I always appreciated it; and the trail was plenty hard, and plenty wild, with or without magic.

Some critics also have claimed, without evidence, that trail magic is responsible for luring more and more — and too often, more unprepared — hikers to the trail. Others accuse trail angels of scrubbing the AT experience of its challenge and making the trail “too easy.”

“Sometimes these acts of generosity (no matter how well-intentioned) may result in additional work for volunteers or may compromise the natural environment,” the ATC declares on its website. “Hikers who only have a few hours or days to enjoy the sanctuary of the AT may not appreciate distractions from the natural environment.”

There’s no question that if done improperly, some forms of trail magic can cause problems. Untended coolers tucked along the trail inevitably attract animals, from hornets to raccoons and bears, which may end up euthanized because they’ve become habituated to humans and human food. And distressingly often, trash from well-intentioned trail magic coolers ends up strewn along the trail.

Most trail denizens can recall the sublime experience of happening upon a “hiker feed,” in which some enterprising angel has laid out a sumptuous spread of food and drink at a road crossing. However, done without proper planning, such gatherings can lead to everything from damage to plant life to litter to an outbreak of viral illness.


appalachian trail massachusetts upper goose pond

AT hiker Bearbait relaxes at Upper Goose Pond in Massachusetts. Photo: Clay Bonnyman Evans.


“It’s frowned upon, a lot of times, if someone thinks that it’s altering your wilderness experience,” says reigning AT trail angel Miss Janet, who travels in her van from Georgia to Maine each year, assisting hikers in countless ways. “But shelters, privies, and road crossings are all things that alter your wilderness experience. Someone standing there offering you a soda, I don’t see how that is altering your experience … unless you are the person who needed that soda really bad that day.”

I’ve also played angel on a few occasions, helping hikers at Partnership Shelter in Virginia, and Kenosha Pass and Durango in Colorado. I’ve given rides to hikers, provided a charging station, snacks and drinks, collected trash, swept shelter floors, and spruced up a privy. And I’ve spent even more time doing less obvious forms of magic, including volunteering with the ATC’s Konnarock Trail Crew, “knocking down” the poop pile at a privy in New Hampshire (it needed to be done, and wasn’t as revolting as I imagined), answering hiker questions from my perch in the “synthetic world,” dispensing and applying yards of Leukotape to pitiful hiker feet (someone tried to give me the trail names “Doc” and “Nursie”), cleaning the bunkhouse or bathroom at hostels, and more.

Myriad Magic

appalachian trail long pond maine

Sunset on Long Pond in Maine. Photo: Clay Bonnyman Evans.

There are countless ways to do magic; you just have to do it right. Rather than scolding angels, conjuring up problems that strain credulity, and placing too much blame on long-distance hikers (who make up less than 1 percent of all AT users each year) those who want to protect the trail might do better to celebrate and promote magic in its nearly limitless incarnations while seeking to cultivate a spirit of giving and gratitude on the trail.

With that in mind, here are positive suggestions for spreading magic

–Expand your definition of magic beyond chow and rides.

–Planning a hiker feed? Cool, but please follow Leave No Trace principles. The ATC offers guidelines for a successful, low-impact event.

–Like most hikers, I always appreciated coming across a cache of goodies in the woods. But to protect the trail and wildlife, do not leave unattended coolers full of food or drinks. Save your much-appreciated generosity until you have time to enjoy your reward by hanging out with the people you are helping.

–Be willing to do whatever needs to be done, whenever and wherever you see it, even while hiking. Spontaneously clean up a shelter, haul out someone else’s trash, report a problem, offer what you have to someone in need — anything that helps hikers, volunteers, and the trail itself.

–Consider volunteering your time with an ATC trail crew or one of the 31 affiliated maintaining clubs that keep the trail open and healthy for millions of annual users, or the equivalent organization on your favorite trail. I suspect most hikers would be astonished by the amount of work it takes to build, say, a series of rock steps, or a bog bridge.

–Donate to organizations that keep your favorite trail in good condition, such as the ATC and its local clubs, Pacific Crest Trail Association, and Colorado Trail Foundation.

–Be creative. Jim Tabor famously has been leaving hand-carved spoons along the trail in Pennsylvania for hikers since 2011; I ran into guy who had hoisted an iced-tea dispenser on his back, Ghostbusters-style, and served hikers on a steamy Pennsylvania ridgetop; on dry stretches of trail, nothing is more welcome than finding clean water left by an angel.

No matter how you decide to give back, always keep the health of the trail in mind.


Feature image: Lindsey “Flash” Gordon

Affiliate Disclosure

This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!

To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.

Comments 4

  • Jean Webb Bonnyman : Jun 13th

    Great advice from a seasoned thru-hiker, who also happens to be my husband’s second cousin. So glad to see you are writing for The Trek, Pony. I will definitely subscribe!

    P.S. Nursie? Ha!

    • Clay Bonnyman Evans : Jun 13th

      Thanks, Jean! I’m psyched to be part of the Trek stable now! ~Pony

  • Arnold "Bloodhound" Guzman : Jul 31st

    Pony, I don’t always have the time to read the Trek articles but I’m glad I read yours, for you have touched upon the subject of trail magic; something that is near and dear to my heart, though often a highly contentious subject among others. I’m surprised that someone hasn’t already ‘ripped you a new one’ over your positive stance on trail magic! I too take food and drink into AT shelters from time to time and like to think that I do it right. For instance, before serving hikers, I don latex serving gloves and keep extra serving gloves for hikers who offer to help me prepare meals. Then I serve each hiker in individual disposable paper plates, bowls and cups, and do not let any hiker touch anything any other hiker touches, nor do I let any hikers serve themselves. I’m careful not to leave any trash and ALWAYS police up the area around the shelters, as well as up and down the trail. In addition, I offer to pack out each hiker’s personal trash before I go. I also carry extra items for hikers, like: paracord, (which has saved one hiker last year when she lost the cord to her bear bag and was sleeping with it every night), AA batteries, toilet paper, HEET (for alcohol stoves, which helped one hiker this year who was out of fuel), Bic lighters and extra flashlights. You see, I don’t have the time nor the desire to thru hike, so doing service to the trail and its hikers is MY way of experiencing the AT and something I’ve loved doing for years. Regardless of how many people that have expressed opposition to what I do, I’m still going to continue doing it for as long as the desire is in my heart. Thanks for taking the time to write this nice article. Sincerely, “Bloodhound”


What Do You Think?