Of All Sad Words of Tongue or Pen
Road Regret
Welp, I’m out.
126 miles on asphalt was simply too much for my cranky hip to bear, and my attempt to thru-hike the 115 highest peaks in the Northeast is over. I have to add “for now,” because otherwise I’m not sure how to bear up under the weight of disappointment.
Now, instead of waking up under some kind tree and walking away the day, my days are filled with visits to the chiro, RICEing my injuries, and limping around the house wondering what-the-heck-happened. Like John on the Island of Patmos, I am marooned in the arid desert of frustrated intention.
I suppose I knew, before I started, that the 100-plus mile road walk between the Catskills and the ADK high peaks was going to be rough.
The rough I imagined, however, was having to find a safe place to stay each night, long stretches of exposure, and loud, gritty traffic.
Walking Route 30 from Grand Gorge, New York, to Northville was all of those things. What I hadn’t foreseen was the cant of the pavement, the crazy tilt of the road that wrecked my joints day after day until, so tantalizingly close to actual soft trail, my knee rebelled and would go no further.
Sigh.
When I finally arrive at the southern terminus of the Northville Placid Trail, I can barely walk.
Head in hands, I ask for guidance – keep going or retreat? I decide to risk the first nine miles, try to see if the cushioned footbed might soothe my aching joints. Make it to the first road crossing and take stock.
People Are Nice
Along the way, at the ford of West Stony Creek, a couple catches up to me, and we squint toward the opposite bank looking for a ribbon or cairn, anything to show where the trail continues. Little do I know that this chance meeting will mean my rescue.
I had expected to find like-minded, generous people along the way on the various trails I would be accessing. The hiker community is known for that. Quite fortuitously, there were also many chance meetings on the road walk with people who helped or inspired me, non-hikers but gifts, nonetheless, of the best of humanity. People like:
- The librarian at the Middleburgh library who patiently coaches me through uploading my first photos from phone to blog and even gives me her own flash drive to take with for future posts.
- The man who, seeing me sitting on the shoulder in the shade of the only tree for miles, turns his truck around and hands me a cold bottle of water.
- Officer Babyface, responding to a call about “some woman sitting on a guardrail,” who tracks me down, chats about my adventure and wonders if he can help in any way. Do you have family? A cell phone? What do you do when it rains? How old are you anyway?
- Later the same day, in the pouring rain, a statie U-turns and offers me a ride. Would that I could have taken it, but this journey is purely perambulant. He waves me luck.
- An elderly gentleman, on a particularly painful morning, who hails me from the opposite side of the street, lifts his arms to indicate mist rising from grassy meadow, sky pinking over dark treeline, and exclaims Isn’t it wonderful? It’s like I’ve met an angel.

- The crew at the Dunks in Vail Mills on Free Donut Day, who allow me to sit for hours at a table and wait out the lightning as I drip rainwater on their clean floor. Seeing me shiver, they even brew me a new, hot batch of coffee. I stuff their tip jar when the weather finally clears.
So, eventually, when my body has had enough and I lurch out of the woods where the NPT crosses Route 6 in Benson, I expect to easily find a ride back into Northville and a way to somehow get home.
Nope.
Car after stubborn car speed by, ignoring the sad soul hunched over her backpack, fighting back tears.
That’s when I hear it: voices. I’d wondered why the couple I met by the West Stony Creek ford hadn’t passed me. Turns out, they went to check out one of the lean-tos and appeared as my knights in shining armor just as I was losing hope.
Sonja doesn’t bat an eye as she invites me to throw muddy pack and broken body into her back seat. Northville? No, you won’t find a way to get home in Northville, but I’ll drive you to the train station at Saratoga Springs.
And just like that, a ticket is bought, and my mission is ended. Leaning on the cold glass of the train window, I let my face leak at last.
There Are No Coincidences
What lessons might I glean from this endeavor? I had planned for over a year, dreamed big dreams, yearned to be in the wild all summer long. Now, summer stretches out like, well, an agonizing road walk, and I’m not quite sure what to do with myself as I recovery from my injuries.
In his poem “Maud Muller,” poet John Greenleaf Whittier penned these famous words:
For of all sad words of tongue or pen,
The saddest are these: It might have been.
I think we all of us, at some point in our lives, have known the slap of setback, the regret of what-if.
But I do not believe in coincidence or even in things that seemingly do not work out. As a woman of faith, I’ve known the perfect timing of a Sovereign Creator too many times to chalk any of this up to chance.
Like the huge snapper I save from certain smushing, turning him around just as his thick neck stretches into traffic, I am right where I’m supposed to be, and when.
Perhaps my wounds will heal in time to try to get out there again soon.
Perhaps not.
Until then, I’ll save my maps and stow my gear, wait for another opening. Sit on the guardrail and watch.
Something good is bound to come by.
This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!
To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.
">








Comments 2
Road walking is so hard on your body and soul. I’m really sorry you had to leave your path. It reminded me of this poem by Sarah Teasdale. Take good care now and “we’ll catch ya down the road”.
Like barley bending
In low fields by the sea,
Singing in hard wind
Ceaselessly;
Like barley bending
And rising again,
So would I, unbroken,
Rise from pain;
So would I softly,
Day long, night long,
Change my sorrow
Into song.
I love that poem, Holly! Yes, waiting for my sorrow to change into song – thanks for sharing 🙂