How NOT to Hike the AT: 5 Questions Bill Bryson Should’ve Asked Himself First

A year ago, after I announced my intentions of hiking the entirety of the Appalachian Trail, about twenty people recommended that I read Bill Bryson’s book A Walk in the WoodsMany of them were absolutely ecstatic, so I was confident I would love the book as well.  However, when I finally read it over the summer, I was disappointed and a bit disgusted with the guy.  I might have been able to get past his general negative attitude about the trail experience, if not for his intolerant insults and bigamist imaginations of the rural south.  Of course, I have yet to embark on my own thru-hike, so I don’t exactly have a right to judge.  Still, I think a different outlook could have led to a better trail experience.  Here are five questions he should have asked himself before beginning his thru-hike.

1. If you’re living for the towns not the mountains, why are you even hiking?

Initially, he reminded me of Bilbo Baggins, who set out rather spontaneously on an adventure for which he was unprepared.

He even forgot his pipe.  #WhiteGuyProblems

He even forgot his pipe. #WhiteGuyProblems

I assumed that, with time, Bryson would come to embrace The Wild just as Bilbo had, but unfortunately that never happened. Sure, he appreciated the breathtaking views from sporadic overlooks, but he never found joy in his lack of urban comforts.  He seemed happiest when he unexpectedly stumbled across processed food or paved roads.  The Hundred Mile Wilderness (which includes the AT’s most difficult climbs and its greatest isolation) sounds like freedom to me, but Bill Bryson was so miserable there that he quit two days in.

2. If you can’t stand the culture of rural America, why did you choose this hike?


In case you have had the luxury of avoiding his over-hyped book, know that he found a creationist statement on a rural church sign so appalling that he skipped over a quarter of the Trail by driving from the southern Smokies all the way to Roanoke.  At this point in the book, Bryson lost my respect, for that section of the Trail is the part most familiar to me and most beloved by me.  That section is where, as a child growing up with the hazy silhouettes of the Smokies outlining the horizon of my city, I first felt a burning desire to retreat from “civilization” and embrace simplicity in the undeveloped forest.  I’m not an experienced backpacker.  I may never hike the Pacific Crest or Continental Divide trails.  I chose the Appalachian Trail, in part, to commune with my homeland in a deeper way.  It’s no surprise that Bryson lost my respect when he failed to appreciate the mountains and the culture so near and dear to my heart.  This is not to say that cultural ties to the AT are a prerequisite for thru-hiking, or even that they lead to a better experience.  Rather, I hope to impress upon any potential thru-hikers that if you cannot appreciate, or at least tolerate, the culture of rural America, this may not be the trail for you.

3.  If you’re going to whine the whole way, could you please spare us all by never writing a book?

Trust me, whiny books have been done before.  Many times.

Trust me, whiny books have been done before. Many times.

Bryson’s failure to tolerate viewpoints different from his own, as expressed by small-town Appalachians, prevented his appreciation of the southern section of the Trail, which in turn led to the failure of his thru-hike.  Aside from his whiny attitude, Bryson’s unpreparedness was a huge problem.  Make no mistake; I am not a spontaneous person, so I have great admiration for people who are.  My point is that Bryson’s intentions were half-baked from the start.  He didn’t do any short backpacking ahead of time to try out his equipment and get in shape.  There’s nothing wrong with unprepared spontaneity, so long as you embrace it.  But instead of embracing it, Bryson spent the whole hike, and the whole book, complaining.

4.  If you’re thru-hiking just to say you did it, can’t you find an easier accomplishment to brag about?

More importantly than this, though, Bryson began hiking for all the wrong reasons.  Essentially, he wanted to hike because “all the cool kids were doing it.”  He wanted to thru-hike for bragging rights, so he could say he had done it.  In some situations, that mindset works well.  For example, I once drank a gallon of milk in less than an hour (56 minutes, to be precise) just to say I had done it.

Dumping milk on your little sister does not count.  But it does entitle you to bragging rights.

Dumping milk on your little sister does not count. But it does entitle you to bragging rights.

It was a difficult task, and my success primarily stemmed from my determination to gain bragging rights.  An AT thru-hike, however, requires a much bigger commitment, and therefore much deeper motivation than “it will make me look cool.”

5.  If you have a better reason to thru-hike, what is it?

There are many good reasons to thru-hike the AT, which may be unique to each person.  I suggest reading Zach Davis’ book for some phenomenal advice on sorting out your personal reasons for pursuing this goal.  Even just by reading A Walk in the Woods, though, I realized my reasons are entirely different from Bryson’s.  I want so desperately to escape from a world where people do things because they’re popular and even more so, I want to escape from the part of myself that so frequently succumbs to that mindset.  I want to distance myself from the material comforts that surround me: from Netflix, from iPhones, from Longchamp bags, because I’m uncomfortable with the effect that materialism has had on me.

If you're the lucky soul who's never seen one of these, go ask any preppy college girl to show you hers.

If you’re the lucky soul who’s never seen one of these, go ask any preppy college girl to show you hers.


If you’re the lucky soul who’s never seen an iPhone, I’m assuming you just arrived here via time machine and I congratulate you on navigating the internet so as to read this post.

If you’re the lucky soul who’s never seen an iPhone, I’m assuming you just arrived here via time machine.  Congratulations on understanding the internet.

The discomforts that Bill Bryson incessantly complained about are what I anticipate; in fact, they are half of the reason I want to hike in the first place.  In an almost monastic way, I look forward to a five-month purge from my indulgent lifestyle.  When at a gift shop in Shenandoah National Park awhile back, I came across a sticker that read, “The Appalachian Trail: a footpath for those who seek solace in the wilderness.”  I bought it, because it so perfectly captured the reason I yearn for the Trail: I am seeking solace.  Although Bill Bryson didn’t find solace in the tranquility of the forest, I know that I will, because I’ve found it there before.  Friends of mine have occasionally remarked that they find it unusual for “such a perfectionist” to harbor an abiding love for The Great Outdoors.  Invariably, I explain that I love being outside precisely because that is the only place where I do not feel compelled to organize, to impose structure upon chaos.  I have no desire to create order when I’m enveloped in Nature, for the natural world is already impeccably perfect in a different way.  I have never found peace of mind as profoundly as I do on a walk in the woods.  I pity poor Bill Bryson that he does not feel the same way.

In Conclusion

And so, to the friends of mine who feared that Bill Bryson’s book would lead me to abandon my Appalachian Trail aspirations, it did not have that effect.  For those of you who hoped it would inspire me, it did so by confirming that I am setting out on this journey for all the right reasons, and with realistic expectations.  To those of you who love this book, I hope I did not spoil it for you, although I look forward to sharing a different perspective with you when I finish the Trail in August.  To those of you who also aspire to hike the AT, I suggest also looking elsewhere for motivation and insight.  Try reading the multitude of other AT books (such as Appalachian Trials), but also read Thoreau’s WaldenChe Guevara’s The Motorcycle Diaries, Tolkien’s The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, and Homer’s The Odyssey.  And to all twenty of you who recommended this book, for varying reasons, thank you so much for doing so.  Despite my dislike for Bill Bryson, I am truly glad I read A Walk in the Woods.

Affiliate Disclosure

This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!

To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.

Comments 5

  • camxyz : Jul 1st

    One notable virtue of the Appalachian Trail is how it connects the disparate cultures of struggling Appalachian hollows with the elitist smugness of metro New York and Ivy League towns. Bryson shows the attitude of the Ivy League town where he lives by assuming that everyone south of the Potomac in the old confederacy is named Bubba and has a gun rack in his pickup truck. He also could have learned something from the couple in Maine who were connecting with the Creator rather than spewing profanity. I guess that the combination of the rugged Smokies and the tourist traps (including the Cherokee casino with Gatlinburg and Dollywood) was enough to make him want to skip the next beautiful portion. No Roan High Knob with the millions of rhododendron blossoms nor the Va. Creeper path nor the ponies of Grayson Highlands park. In my experience, Waynesboro is quite walkable with a footpath along the Shenandoah South Fork. It’s a shame that he didn’t like the non-touristy town. He needs to write a sequel with the best parts that he missed the first time. I’m glad that nobody drowned or froze to death in his account.

  • Suzanne : Dec 31st

    How can you write an article like this when you haven’t even thru hiked it. Maybe you can take a lesson from your own writing: Bryson’s failure to tolerate viewpoints different from his own. Ever heard of hike your own hike? Wow, with your attitude I doubt you will be successful. Good luck though.

  • Suzanne : Dec 31st

    How can you write an article like this when you haven’t even thru hiked it. Maybe you can take a lesson from your own writing: Bryson’s failure to tolerate viewpoints different from his own. Ever heard of hike your own

  • Jamie : May 15th

    I think you approached this book from the wrong angle. It was meant to be an easy, humorous read, which it was for most people who took it in that vein. Bryson was a not-so-in-shape, late middle-aged baby boomer who was writing for a similar audience. Most of us who resemble that description found it interesting, funny, and relatable. I doubt it was aimed at young, healthy, millennials like yourself who have not yet experienced what it is like to spend several decades building your adult life and finding yourself questioning your purpose in life as you begin to sense your mortality. Yeah, he made mistakes, yeah he was underprepared, yeah he has a bit of a sarcastic wit, but that’s what makes him so approachable. His book was not meant to be an inspiration to others to attempt to walk the AT, though it has done that, I’m sure much more than your insipid little article for Trek.

  • Doctari : Aug 1st

    MY opinion: Bryson’s stories were gleaned from other hiker’s journals & his own imagination (is: its a work of fiction). AND, I know many of those he bigotedly slammed,,, they never met him!
    Save your money, don’t buy “Walk” there are MANY other & better books out there, written by actual hikers.
    Again, MY opinion.


What Do You Think?