Goldilocks and the Six Sleeping Pads

It’s November and fall has finally arrived in East Tennessee. That means I have been itching to get outside, and try to sneak hikes or even overnight trips into my busy schedule. Last week Isaac and I hiked up to the fire tower on top of Chilhowee Mountain in Great Smoky Mountains National Park. It’s just a 15- minute drive from our home, up a treacherous mountain road to Foothills Parkway, a famous scenic route through the park.

Unfortunately, we’ve run into a dilemma.

I have had a bear of a time finding the sleeping pad that is just right (sorry, not sorry). In the past three months I’ve tried six different sleeping pads. Six. As of right now, I still don’t have a pad that I like. I’ve been using a $7 blue foam pad from Walmart, which I briefly mentioned in my last post. It’s not much better than sleeping on the ground. Not having a sleeping pad means that our backpacking trips have been put on a temporary hold, and we can’t take advantage of the perfect weather.

Sleeping Pad Failures

  1. Therm-a-Rest Z-Lite Sol (Short)
  2. Klymit Insulated Static V
  3. Klymit Static V2
  4. Klymit Static V junior
  5. Walmart Foam Pad
  6. Klymit Static V

Z-Lite Sol

My sleeping pad journey started with a Z-Lite Sol, which I purchased from REI almost a year ago. Before then, I had been borrowing random sleeping pads from friends. The Z-Lite is a classic, and I liked the easy setup and lightness of it. But after a three-night backing trip at Panthertown Valley over Labor Day, my back told me that we needed an upgrade.

Klymit Insulated Static V

I did some research and decided that this pad seemed like a good choice. I had not bought my new five-degree sleeping bag yet, and because I am generally a cold sleeper I decided to go with a pad that had a high R-value (check this link to learn about R-values). The Insulated Static V has an R-value of 4.4, which is pretty good. I ordered directly from Klymit, and got the pad in a little under a week. It was comfortable, but the large size caused me to return it. When rolled up and put into the stuff sack, the Insulated V was about four inches by six inches. That’s just a bit larger than a standard Nalgene bottle. This plus the fact that it weighs over a pound led me to decide I wanted something significantly more compact.

Klymit Static V2

Next I purchased the Static V2.  I decided to stick with Klymit because I really like the combination of reasonable prices and great design that the brand offers. I did, however, order through Amazon because I found a better deal there. The V2 was great, and I would have kept it if it wasn’t for one fatal flaw… It was really crinkly! Isaac used this pad on a trip with his friends and told me that if I brought it on the AT he’d probably kill me. Obviously, the pad had to go. I returned it to Amazon and kept looking.

Klymit Static V Junior

After I bought my Zpacks five-degree sleeping bag, I thought that maybe I didn’t need much insulation. Klymit pads are a bit long for me, and I sleep with my feet on my pack, anyway. It seemed logical to go with a shorter pad, so I tried out the Static V Junior. This pad is probably my second least favorite, behind the crappy blue foam pad from Walmart. The Junior would probably be a good summer pad if Klymit had stuck to its usual valve. Unfortunately, this pad has a valve on each side of the pad, with one to inflate and one to deflate. I found this awkward and the pad I received did not hold air. I also found that my feet were cold in even in my very warm sleeping bag with my feet on my pack.

Walmart Blue Closed-Cell Foam Pad

No. Just no.

Klymit Static V

After all of these failures, I decided to go with the original. Isaac uses a regular Static V and it has done exceptionally well. It’s made of 75 denier polyester, so the pad’s durability is far superior to most others on the market. The valve is fairly intuitive and Isaac’s has never lost air. I ordered one from Amazon for a little cheaper than they are on the Klymit website, in this discontinued camo color (it was the cheapest option). Unfortunately, on both of the nights that I used the pad it lost a significant amount of air. I woke up entirely on the ground on the second morning and decided that it was definitely not working. I contacted Klymit and they have agreed to send me a new Static V.

Hopefully, the new Static V will be the answer to all of my prayers. I’ll keep y’all updated. Until then, happy hiking.

Note: Product images from thermarest.com, klymit.com, and amazon.com. Cover image taken by Isaac Luhrs.

Affiliate Disclosure

This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!

To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.

Comments 4

  • Annemarie : Nov 8th

    Maybe a hammock is in your future?!

    Reply
    • Phoebe : Nov 9th

      Lol! I like hammock camping in the summer alright, but weirdly they tend to hurt my back. I need more solid support!

      Reply
  • Phoebe : Nov 11th

    Update: Got the static V from Klymit last week and used it on the trail Friday & Saturday night with great success. Yay!

    Reply
    • Will Skelton : Nov 15th

      Are you set on a solid pad? I’ve for years used a blowup pad and they’re for me a lot better. I have for some time used a Therm-a-Rest NeoAir 3/4th length. Of course you have to blow it up and be careful not to puncture it (a repair kit is available), I’ve never had a problem with mine. I’d even loan you mine if you want to try it out, they weight almost nothing and compress really small compared to the solid pads.

      Reply

What Do You Think?