Day 94: Goodbye, Pennsylvania!

On a Mission

My feet were a little hammered from yesterday’s marathon, but they wanted out of Rocksylvania, so they were up with socks on and shoes laced up almost before I was. We’d boondocked right at the trail crossing in Wind Gap, so I only had to stumble out the door and start climbing.

Same Old Same Old

PUDslyvania said its goodbyes the same way it had said its hellos for the past two weeks – a steep, sweaty climb out of the gap, and then a rocky ridge walk through the long green tunnel. Today’s ridge started with seven miles of imbedded pointy rocks, and a few rock rivers thrown in for good measure.

Then came Wolf Rocks, a bedrock outcrop just high enough to see out over a tree-covered terrace below. Comments on the FarOut app promised copperheads and rattlesnakes sunning themselves on the ankle-busting cliffs. No snakes were out this morning, so I had to settle for a trio of buzzards that let me walk up to within 10 feet before they slowly flapped their wings and lumbered away.

Roll Call

After that, six more slightly less rocky, but still viewless, miles took me to the Delaware River overlook where I stopped for an early lunch and a look at the river below. Besides a couple of day hikers, I passed only two thru hikers all day.

The first was an older guy, hiking solo of course, who said his name was “Jon – J-O-N,” spelling it out for me. He said someone had tried out “Jontana,” after his home state, but it didn’t stick. The second was a young man named Fizz, who I hadn’t seen since the Blue Ridge Parkway. He asked about Gus, chatted a bit, and disappeared down the hill.

Straight Outta’ PA

I walked into the town of Delaware Water Gap just before noon, met Northstar, and walked with her and Gus across the bridge to New Jersey. I brought a little pile of rocks to mound up on the Pennsylvania side of the boundary sign and left them there as an offering.

In a fitting reminder of what I hope we’re leaving behind, we saw a pair of twenty-somethings approaching the bridge as we returned to the van. They saw us, crossed to the other side of the road, and passed by without a wave or a nod.


I won’t miss Pennsylvania. Rockslyvania. PUDslyvania. Tickslyvania. Hotslyvania. But I feel a little sorry for the state. It can’t help the miserable weather we had for the last two weeks, the tick infestation, or the local geology, but the ATC could have done more with the trail.

The long rocky sections are ridiculously unpleasant. I’ve hiked lots of rocky trails. I fully expect mountain trails to be rocky in places. My home trails in Arizona are rocky. But after two weeks walking the trail through Pennsylvania, I’m convinced the AT does not need to be so rocky.

Rocky Trails Are a Choice

I believe the Pennsylvania AT is rocky primarily because of poor trail building. Sure, the geology creates rocky conditions, some of which can’t be avoided, but consider the following:

  1. The bedrock that lies under the AT doesn’t change much in Pennsylvania, but the annoyingly rocky sections don’t begin until well north of Duncannon. The rocky and non-rocky trail sections north of Duncannon have the same bedrock geology. We can’t blame the geology.
  2. Stagecoach Roads. Between Duncannon and Bordnersville, I walked almost ten miles along a 170-year-old former stagecoach road that was one of the smoothest trail sections in Pennsylvania. If road builders in the 1850’s could figure out how to build smooth trails through the Appalachians that have lasted almost two centuries, I’m pretty sure the ATC could too.
  3. Forest Roads. The same argument applies to the smooth-as-butter forest roads I walked. They cover the same terrain and have more restrictive right-of-way requirements as the AT but are smooth enough for wheeled travel. If forest roads (and old wagon roads) can be rockless, the AT could be too.
  4. New Trail Sections. The beautiful new trails near Palmerton also prove that the foot trails on Pennsylvania’s ridges don’t have to be rocky. It may take more work to build non-rocky trails, but it can be done.

In my career, I’ve worked on dozens of road alignment, bridge design, and planning studies. I completely understand about budget, right-of-way, jurisdictional, environmental, and political constraints. Sometimes roads and bridges get put in places that don’t make sense one to particular stakeholder. I’m sure the same is true for trail building.

I also know that AT thru hikers’ foot comfort wasn’t the only or primary concern when the AT was built. That said, much of the AT in Pennsylvania is a crappy trail. We could have done better. In some places in Pennsylvania, we have done better. We should fix the rest of it.

Time For a Day Off

Whew. I had to get that off my chest. Feel free to disagree. I found lots to like in Pennsylvania, but I had to work a little harder to find it. I’m guessing that it would be easier to find in Spring or Fall.

But I’m very happy I’m hiking in New Jersey now.

Daily Stats:

  • Start: Wind Gap (Mile 1281.4)
  • End: New Jersey (Mile 1297.2)
  • Weather: Overcast, smoky, humid, warm. Occasional drizzle.
  • Earworm: Hosanna. Again. Sigh.
  • Meditation: Mark 12:30
  • Plant of the Day: Water lily
  • Best Thing: Done with PA
  • Worst Thing (besides the humidity): Sore feet


Affiliate Disclosure

This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price as they would otherwise, and your purchase helps to support The Trek's ongoing goal to serve you quality backpacking advice and information. Thanks for your support!

To learn more, please visit the About This Site page.

Comments 15

  • thetentman : Jul 22nd

    Nice rant. It sucks when your feet hurt and it is humid and there are bugs and PUDs.

    You should run for office at the ATC.

    A friend of mine, who was the top guy (paid) at a large trail club said of the volunteers, who maintained the trails, that it was like herding cats.

    I am glad I hiked PA when it was bad, but agree that it could be much better.

    • Lulu : Jul 23rd

      Great description, and true…”herding cats”. Made me laugh out loud. thanks

    • Jon : Jul 23rd

      My cat herding days are over. My ranting days have just begun.

  • DCAlaneKnits : Jul 23rd

    I have had two burning questions and I guess it’s time to ask .

    I did find an Instagram post/story about the van build out. I’m curious to know if you have any other descriptions someplace?

    Also, what does Northstar do besides scouting out the next position while you are walking? I envision a lot of guilt-free reading or crafting!

    One of my favorite trogs? (Trail blog)

    • Lulu : Jul 23rd

      Yeah, van build-out please at some point! love this blog. thanks

    • Jon : Jul 23rd

      I’ll try to do a van blog on our next zero day. Good suggestion.

      • Jon : Jul 23rd

        We’ll see if we can get Northstar to answer that.

  • GearNerd : Jul 23rd

    Glacial maximum have anything to do with the deposits? (I know I should just check a map)

    • Jon : Jul 23rd

      My last glacial geology class was 41 years ago, but seem to recall that the last glaciation (Wisconsin) didn’t extend past NY. But some of the rock rivers probably date to that period.

  • Don : Jul 23rd

    I have lived 5 miles from Wind Gap for 30 years. I get up on the trail maybe 4 times a year, at various locations along the Blue Mountain, and read your well-deserved rant with interest. I an not an experienced hiker, but the rocky nature of the AT in this area makes it unwelcome for me personally.

    • Jon : Jul 23rd


  • CB : Jul 23rd

    Great post! We’ll mark you down as undecided on your feelings for PA.

    • Jon : Jul 26th



What Do You Think?